Audiences preferred Poster

I showed 20 people the 4 posters i have created and asked which one they preferred and why?

Poster 1 ( 3 people preferred)
Poster 3 (5 People preferred)
Poster 2 (5 People Preferred)
Poster 4 (7 People Preferred)


Comments from the first poster :

• I like how the picture fits the text
• The picture is to dark
• The text is very funky and funny

Second:

• I love the picture, the space in between him and the drink is perfect
• The writing fits the picture
• To many colors in the back ground

Third : 

• The writing fits perfectly at the bottom of the page
• Background is not to good
• The characters facial expression fits the photo

Fourth:

• The writing in the center of the page fits perfectly with the image
• The slogan at the bottom of the page fits nicely with the text and image
• The colors of the picture and text all work nicely